Jump to content

Asus Charges for Free Service: Difference between revisions

From Consumer_Action_Taskforce
← Older editNewer edit →
Visual
No edit summary
Tag: 2017 source edit
added pictures and reworked article.
Line 1: Line 1:
== Boot Loader Unlocking Controversy ==
==Boot Loader Unlocking Controversy==
The ASUS boot loader unlocking tool disappearing is a prime example of how device ownership rights have eroded, where functionality that was present at the time of sale is no longer present years down the line.  
The ASUS boot loader unlocking tool disappearing is a prime example of how device ownership rights have eroded, where functionality that was present at the time of sale is no longer present years down the line.  


=== Background ===
===Background===
ASUS used to provide free bootloader unlocking capabilities for their Zenfone & Republic of Gamers (ROG) Android phones.<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref> This feature was actively advertised & was part of the company's appeal to tech-savvy consumers.
ASUS used to provide free bootloader unlocking capabilities for their Zenfone & Republic of Gamers (ROG) Android phones.<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref> This feature was actively advertised & was part of the company's appeal to tech-savvy consumers.


=== Timeline of Events ===
===Timeline of Events===
* In May 2023, ASUS disabled their bootloader unlocking tools without warning<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
*In May 2023, ASUS disabled their bootloader unlocking tools without warning<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
* The company began removing posts about bootloader unlocking from their ZenTalk forums<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
*The company began removing posts about bootloader unlocking from their ZenTalk forums<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
* Forum moderators claimed the tools were "under maintenance" or being "overhauled for compliance reasons" without providing timeframes for restoration<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
*Forum moderators claimed the tools were "under maintenance" or being "overhauled for compliance reasons" without providing timeframes for restoration<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
* By early 2024, ASUS began charging approximately €185 (excluding VAT) for bootloader unlocking<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356</ref>
*By early 2024, ASUS began charging approximately €185 (excluding VAT) for bootloader unlocking<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356</ref>


=== Impact ===
===Impact===
This issue goes over several key consumer protection concerns:
This issue goes over several key consumer protection concerns:


* '''Removal of Advertised Features''': The bootloader unlocking capability was an advertised feature that influenced people's buying decision, which was later removed.
*'''Removal of Advertised Features''': The bootloader unlocking capability was an advertised feature that influenced people's buying decision, which was later removed.
* '''Lack of Transparency''': ASUS provided minimal communication about the change in policy, with documented cases of forum posts being removed & only vague explanations being provided<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
*'''Lack of Transparency''': ASUS provided minimal communication about the change in policy, with documented cases of forum posts being removed & only vague explanations being provided<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
* '''Monetization of Previously Free Features''': The transition from a free service to a paid one, costing €185 (excluding VAT), is a significant change in the product's pricing structure after purchase<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356</ref>
*'''Monetization of Previously Free Features''': The transition from a free service to a paid one, costing €185 (excluding VAT), is a significant change in the product's pricing structure after purchase<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356</ref>
* '''Extended Device Lifespan Impact''': The change affects consumers' ability to maintain & update their devices beyond ASUS's official support window, which has been documented as "one of the worst software support commitments in the Android world"<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
*'''Extended Device Lifespan Impact''': The change affects consumers' ability to maintain & update their devices beyond ASUS's official support window, which has been documented as "one of the worst software support commitments in the Android world"<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
[[File:Lawsuit against asus over bootloader unlocking.jpg|thumb|Document of customer small claims suit against ASUS over bootloader unlocking. Credit Mishaal Rahman on twitter <ref>https://x.com/MishaalRahman/status/1776306579979047083</ref> for this document showing the customer suit against ASUS]]
[[File:ASUS concedes defeat to customer who filed small claims court suit.png|alt=email from ASUS in response to customer small claims suit against ASUS over bootloader unlocking. |thumb|email from ASUS in response to customer small claims suit against ASUS over bootloader unlocking.  Credit to Mishaal Rahman on twitter for providing the screenshot.  <ref>https://x.com/MishaalRahman/status/1776306579979047083/photo/1


=== Legal Implications ===
</ref>]]
 
===Legal Implications===
This led to at least one successful legal challenge. In March 2024, a UK customer took ASUS to small claims court over this and got a full refund for both the device & the court fees, totaling £770 (~$973). This case potentially sets a precedent for other consumers affected by the policy change.<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>
This led to at least one successful legal challenge. In March 2024, a UK customer took ASUS to small claims court over this and got a full refund for both the device & the court fees, totaling £770 (~$973). This case potentially sets a precedent for other consumers affected by the policy change.<ref>https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/</ref>


=== Consumer Response ===
===Consumer Response===
The response from the consumer community has been notably negative, with documented concerns about:
The response from the consumer community has been notably negative, with documented concerns about:
* The high cost of the unlocking service (€185 excluding VAT)<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356</ref>
*The high cost of the unlocking service (€185 excluding VAT)<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356</ref>
* The principle of charging for a previously free feature<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>
*The principle of charging for a previously free feature<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>


=== EU Warranty Implications ===
===EU Warranty Implications===
The controversy has additional implications in the European Union, where:
This has additional implications in the European Union, where:
* It is illegal to deny warranty repairs based on software modifications<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>
*It is illegal to deny warranty repairs based on software modifications<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>
* ASUS has been reported to deny warranty service for devices with unlocked bootloaders, despite this legal protection<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>
*ASUS has been reported to deny warranty service for devices with unlocked bootloaders, despite this legal protection<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>
* The company has offered "one time warranty repairs" with the condition of relocking the bootloader<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>
*The company has offered "one time warranty repairs" with the condition of relocking the bootloader<ref>https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/</ref>


== References ==
==References==
<references/>
<references />


[[Category:Modern consumer exploitation]]
[[Category:Modern consumer exploitation]]

Revision as of 23:32, 11 February 2025

Boot Loader Unlocking Controversy

The ASUS boot loader unlocking tool disappearing is a prime example of how device ownership rights have eroded, where functionality that was present at the time of sale is no longer present years down the line.

Background

ASUS used to provide free bootloader unlocking capabilities for their Zenfone & Republic of Gamers (ROG) Android phones.[1] This feature was actively advertised & was part of the company's appeal to tech-savvy consumers.

Timeline of Events

  • In May 2023, ASUS disabled their bootloader unlocking tools without warning[2]
  • The company began removing posts about bootloader unlocking from their ZenTalk forums[3]
  • Forum moderators claimed the tools were "under maintenance" or being "overhauled for compliance reasons" without providing timeframes for restoration[4]
  • By early 2024, ASUS began charging approximately €185 (excluding VAT) for bootloader unlocking[5]

Impact

This issue goes over several key consumer protection concerns:

  • Removal of Advertised Features: The bootloader unlocking capability was an advertised feature that influenced people's buying decision, which was later removed.
  • Lack of Transparency: ASUS provided minimal communication about the change in policy, with documented cases of forum posts being removed & only vague explanations being provided[6]
  • Monetization of Previously Free Features: The transition from a free service to a paid one, costing €185 (excluding VAT), is a significant change in the product's pricing structure after purchase[7]
  • Extended Device Lifespan Impact: The change affects consumers' ability to maintain & update their devices beyond ASUS's official support window, which has been documented as "one of the worst software support commitments in the Android world"[8]
Document of customer small claims suit against ASUS over bootloader unlocking. Credit Mishaal Rahman on twitter [9] for this document showing the customer suit against ASUS
email from ASUS in response to customer small claims suit against ASUS over bootloader unlocking.
email from ASUS in response to customer small claims suit against ASUS over bootloader unlocking. Credit to Mishaal Rahman on twitter for providing the screenshot. [10]

Legal Implications

This led to at least one successful legal challenge. In March 2024, a UK customer took ASUS to small claims court over this and got a full refund for both the device & the court fees, totaling £770 (~$973). This case potentially sets a precedent for other consumers affected by the policy change.[11]

Consumer Response

The response from the consumer community has been notably negative, with documented concerns about:

  • The high cost of the unlocking service (€185 excluding VAT)[12]
  • The principle of charging for a previously free feature[13]

EU Warranty Implications

This has additional implications in the European Union, where:

  • It is illegal to deny warranty repairs based on software modifications[14]
  • ASUS has been reported to deny warranty service for devices with unlocked bootloaders, despite this legal protection[15]
  • The company has offered "one time warranty repairs" with the condition of relocking the bootloader[16]

References

  1. ↑ https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/
  2. ↑ https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/
  3. ↑ https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/
  4. ↑ https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/
  5. ↑ https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356
  6. ↑ https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/
  7. ↑ https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356
  8. ↑ https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/
  9. ↑ https://x.com/MishaalRahman/status/1776306579979047083
  10. ↑ https://x.com/MishaalRahman/status/1776306579979047083/photo/1
  11. ↑ https://www.androidauthority.com/asus-bootloader-unlock-settlement-3431818/
  12. ↑ https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/post-89720356
  13. ↑ https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/
  14. ↑ https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/
  15. ↑ https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/
  16. ↑ https://xdaforums.com/t/asus-says-they-will-unlock-my-bootloader-for-money.4685488/
Retrieved from "https://wiki.rossmanngroup.com/index.php?title=Asus_Charges_for_Free_Service&oldid=8839"