Jump to content

Brilliant: Difference between revisions

From Consumer_Action_Taskforce
Added a tone warning.
HeavenPiercerYama (talk | contribs)
Tone change and added logo
Line 5: Line 5:
| Industry = Online education
| Industry = Online education
| Official Website = https://brilliant.org
| Official Website = https://brilliant.org
| Logo = QuestionMark.svg
| Logo = Brilliant logo.png
}}
}}
'''[[wikipedia:Brilliant_(website)|Brilliant]]''' (also known as '''Brilliant.org''') is a website and app by '''Brilliant Worldwide, Inc.''' providing online courses. Despite the “.org”, Brilliant is a regular for-profit corporation backed by venture capitalists. Brilliant is most known for its persistent parasocial advertisements on [[YouTube]], in which presenters who are otherwise known for their evidence-based points of view, or are even known for scrutinizing and refuting pseudoscience and scams, promote Brilliant with claims not backed up by evidence. Apart from sponsored segments, there are barely any videos about Brilliant on YouTube.
'''[[wikipedia:Brilliant_(website)|Brilliant]]''' (also known as '''Brilliant.org''') is a website and app by '''Brilliant Worldwide, Inc.''' providing online courses. Despite the “.org”, Brilliant is a for-profit corporation backed by venture capitalists. Brilliant is most known for its advertisements on [[YouTube]], in which presenters who are known for their evidence-based points of view, for scrutinizing and refuting pseudoscience and scams, promote Brilliant.


[[File:Brilliant_content_team.png|thumb|Professors? Overrated. We have a “content team”.]]
[[File:Brilliant_content_team.png|thumb|An example of the content on the website. ]]


Brilliant functions similarly to mathematics textbook, but with buttons to click through to get to the next paragraph, and simple quizzes sprinkled between paragraphs. Some of the illustrations have a bit of interactivity, mostly just a slider that can be dragged around. These interactive elements make Brilliant appear to offer more than a traditional textbook, when it is presented in promotional segments on YouTube. There is no evidence, however, that they provide additional educational value beyond non-interactive illustrations.
Brilliant functions similarly to mathematics textbook, but with buttons to click through to get to the next paragraph, and quizzes between paragraphs. Some of the illustrations have interactivity, in a lot of cases a slider that can be dragged around. These interactive elements make Brilliant appear to offer more than a traditional textbook.  


[[File:Brilliant_slider.png|thumb|To solve this quiz question, drag the slider to point at the same place as the point marked on the curve, as instructed by the text before the quiz. The slider is initially in the wrong place just to force the user to interact with it, to keep up the illusion of learning by doing. Once the slider is in the right place, the illustration automatically shows the correct answer. Press the button with the same answer as displayed in the illustration. No thinking required.]]
[[File:Brilliant_slider.png|thumb|The slider in the picture seems to provide no real challenge in solving it, merely needing to be displaced to solve the puzzle. ]]


Brilliant never promotes itself as being appropriate to a particular audience studying for a particular goal. For this reason, Brilliant can work as a content farm and have a “content team” (officially called so) producing random courses without having to pay authorized teachers and professors to design and validate courses that are useful for passing a particular exam or applying for a particular job. Courses on Brilliant therefore introduce basic concepts of each subject, but with no independent validation or accreditation for their efficacy.
Brilliant never promotes itself as being appropriate to a particular audience studying for a particular goal. Courses on Brilliant introduce basic concepts of each subject, but with no independent validation or accreditation for their efficacy.


==Terms of use==
==Terms of use==
Line 25: Line 25:


===Billing and payment===
===Billing and payment===
The price advertised by Brilliant may not be the actual price a customer would be required to pay. The actual price has undisclosed additional taxes added:<blockquote>All fees are exclusive of applicable taxes (e.g. sales, use, or value-added tax), unless otherwise stated, and User is solely responsible for the payment of any such taxes that may be imposed on your use of the Service.</blockquote>If a customer cancels his payment card to prevent further charges, Brilliant may go directly to the card issuer to request confidential records of any new card belonging to the consumer:<blockquote>User authorizes Brilliant to obtain updated or replacement expiration dates and card numbers for User's credit or debit card as provided by User's credit or debit card issuer.</blockquote>Again, Brilliant may cancel access to the service that the consumer has payed for at any time without offering a refund:<blockquote>Except as expressly provided in the “Refunds” section below, all fees are final and nonrefundable (including in the event any features or functions of any service that User has subscribed to are changed, modified, diminished or removed), except as otherwise required by applicable law.</blockquote>
The price advertised by Brilliant may not be the actual price a customer would be required to pay. The actual price has undisclosed additional taxes added:<blockquote>All fees are exclusive of applicable taxes (e.g. sales, use, or value-added tax), unless otherwise stated, and User is solely responsible for the payment of any such taxes that may be imposed on your use of the Service.</blockquote>If a customer cancels his payment card to prevent further charges, Brilliant may go directly to the card issuer to request confidential records of any new card belonging to the consumer:<blockquote>User authorizes Brilliant to obtain updated or replacement expiration dates and card numbers for User's credit or debit card as provided by User's credit or debit card issuer.</blockquote>To reitirate, Brilliant may cancel access to the service that the consumer has payed for at any time without offering a refund:<blockquote>Except as expressly provided in the “Refunds” section below, all fees are final and nonrefundable (including in the event any features or functions of any service that User has subscribed to are changed, modified, diminished or removed), except as otherwise required by applicable law.</blockquote>


===Automatic renewal===
===Automatic renewal===

Revision as of 06:49, 30 January 2025


⚠️ Article status notice: This article has been marked as incomplete

This article needs additional work to meet the wiki's Content Guidelines and be in line with our Mission Statement for comprehensive coverage of consumer protection issues.

This notice will be removed once sufficient documentation has been added to establish the systemic nature of these issues. Once you believe the article is ready to have its notice removed, visit the discord and post to the #appeals channel.

Learn more ▼


Article Status Notice: Unacceptable Tone/Word Usage

Notice: This Article Requires Change in Tone

This article needs additional work to meet the wiki's Content Guidelines and be in line with our Mission Statement for comprehensive coverage of consumer protection issues. Specifically it uses wording throughout that is non-compliant with the Editorial guidelines of this wiki.

How You Can Help:

If this is a non-Theme article:

  • Persuasive language should not be used in the Wiki's voice. Avoid loaded words, or the causing of unnecessary offense, wherever possible.
  • No direct attacks on named individuals or companies. Malice may be attributed to bad and proven offenders, but only through the use of quotation and citation - never in the Wiki's voice.

If this is a Theme article:

  • Where argumentation is used make sure it is clear and direct but not inflammatory. Avoid strong language, or causing unnecessary offense.
  • No direct attacks on named individuals or companies. Malice may be attributed to bad and proven offenders, in a formal and calm manner.

This notice will be removed once sufficient documentation has been added to establish the systemic nature of these issues. Once you believe the article is ready to have its notice removed, visit the Discord (join here) and post to the #appeals channel.

Brilliant
Basic information
Founded 2012
Type Private
Industry Online education
Official website https://brilliant.org

Brilliant (also known as Brilliant.org) is a website and app by Brilliant Worldwide, Inc. providing online courses. Despite the “.org”, Brilliant is a for-profit corporation backed by venture capitalists. Brilliant is most known for its advertisements on YouTube, in which presenters who are known for their evidence-based points of view, for scrutinizing and refuting pseudoscience and scams, promote Brilliant.

An example of the content on the website.

Brilliant functions similarly to mathematics textbook, but with buttons to click through to get to the next paragraph, and quizzes between paragraphs. Some of the illustrations have interactivity, in a lot of cases a slider that can be dragged around. These interactive elements make Brilliant appear to offer more than a traditional textbook.

The slider in the picture seems to provide no real challenge in solving it, merely needing to be displaced to solve the puzzle.

Brilliant never promotes itself as being appropriate to a particular audience studying for a particular goal. Courses on Brilliant introduce basic concepts of each subject, but with no independent validation or accreditation for their efficacy.

Terms of use

The terms of service for Brilliant say:[1]

Brilliant reserves the right, at its sole discretion, to modify or replace any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement at any time. It is User's responsibility to check this Agreement periodically for changes. User's continued use of the Service following the posting of any changes to this Agreement constitutes acceptance of those changes.

Even if the consumer has paid for a full year of service, therefore, Brilliant can change its terms and conditions after the sale. Continuing to use the service that the consumer has paid for under the previous terms of service automatically constitutes acceptance of changes.

Access

Brilliant may cancel access to the service that the consumer has paid for at any time without offering a refund:

Brilliant may change, suspend or discontinue the Services, including the availability of any feature, database or content, at any time. Brilliant may also impose limits on certain features and services or restrict User's access to parts or all of the Services without notice or liability.

If the law grants the consumer rights that are illegally denied by the terms of use, the consumer is locked out from accessing the service:

User also certifies that User is legally permitted to use the Service and takes full responsibility for the selection and use of the Service. This Agreement is void where prohibited by law, and the right to access the Service is revoked in such jurisdictions.

Billing and payment

The price advertised by Brilliant may not be the actual price a customer would be required to pay. The actual price has undisclosed additional taxes added:

All fees are exclusive of applicable taxes (e.g. sales, use, or value-added tax), unless otherwise stated, and User is solely responsible for the payment of any such taxes that may be imposed on your use of the Service.

If a customer cancels his payment card to prevent further charges, Brilliant may go directly to the card issuer to request confidential records of any new card belonging to the consumer:

User authorizes Brilliant to obtain updated or replacement expiration dates and card numbers for User's credit or debit card as provided by User's credit or debit card issuer.

To reitirate, Brilliant may cancel access to the service that the consumer has payed for at any time without offering a refund:

Except as expressly provided in the “Refunds” section below, all fees are final and nonrefundable (including in the event any features or functions of any service that User has subscribed to are changed, modified, diminished or removed), except as otherwise required by applicable law.

Automatic renewal

Brilliant automatically renews user subscriptions without active user acceptance. Thus, customers who have lost interest in the service and have otherwise forgotten about it may be caught by surprise when they receive a charge at the start of a new subscription cycle. The annual subscription cycle also tacitly assumes that users want to use the service uninterrupted for a full year, which ignores use-cases where customers may want only to study at a particular time of the year.

When Brilliant lowers its prices, existing customers will still be charged the previous higher prices on renewal, though they are protected from price increases by the same policy:

User's subscription to the Service will continue indefinitely until cancelled by User (via the cancellation mechanisms provided on the Site). After User's initial subscription period, and again after any subsequent subscription period, User's subscription will automatically continue for an additional equivalent period, at the price User agreed to when subscribing.

By using the service, the user is automatically opted in to the automatic renewal, and there is no option to not agree to it:

User agrees that User's account will be subject to this automatic renewal feature.

Subscription itself authorizes Brilliant to periodically charge customers' credit cards on automatically renewal, again including undisclosed additional taxes:

By subscribing, User authorizes Brilliant to charge User's credit card, debit card or other payment method at such time and again at the beginning of any subsequent subscription period, including any sales or similar taxes imposed on User's subscription payments.

Refunds

Brilliant may grant refunds to customers at its sole discretion:

All payments To Brilliant for the Services are nonrefundable. There are no refunds or credits for partially used subscription periods. However, Brilliant may grant refunds or credits on a case-by-case basis at Brilliant’s sole discretion. Brilliant’s grant of a refund or credit in one instance does not obligate Brilliant to provide a refund or credit in the future, under any circumstances.

Promotions

The seven-day free trial is a free-to-pay scheme: a one-year paid subscription with a seven-day cancellation period:

Brilliant may offer promotions, such as free trials, discounts, or other special offers, to users from time to time (collectively, “Promotions”). Promotions may be subject to specific terms, including a defined period during which the Promotion must be redeemed and utilized (each, a “Promotion Period”). Unless otherwise stated, any use of a Promotion will automatically convert into a paid subscription for the Services upon the expiration of the Promotional Period. Users are responsible for canceling their subscription before the end of the Promotional Period to avoid incurring any charges (or, in the case of a discount Promotion, to avoid additional charges). Failure to cancel within the Promotional Period will result in the applicable subscription fee being charged to the payment method provided at the time of sign-up or as updated by User.

Site content

Brilliant may only appear in YouTube videos with the express permission of Brilliant, which suggests that only those paid by the company to say pre-approved messages are allowed to display its product.

Reproducing, copying or distributing any content, materials or design elements on the Site for any purpose is strictly prohibited without the express prior written permission of Brilliant.

Termination

Brilliant may cancel access to the service that a customer has paid for at any time, without explanation:

Brilliant may terminate User's access to all or any part of the Service at any time, with or without cause, effective upon notice thereof to User (provided that, if Brilliant determines there may be an immediate threat to Brilliant, it may terminate such access without notice).

Forced arbitration

Local consumer rights may not apply to the agreement. According to the terms of service, with respect to their agreement with Brilliant, customers are governed by the laws of Pennsylvania, but not to its courts, instead agreeing to submit to the jurisdiction of the courts in California.

This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the state of Pennsylvania, as if made within Pennsylvania between two residents thereof, and the parties submit to the exclusive jurisdiction and venue of the state and Federal courts located in San Francisco, California.

Customers forgo the right for legal action, instead being subject to forced arbitration by a private company:

Notwithstanding the foregoing sentence, (but without limiting either party's right to seek injunctive or other equitable relief immediately, at any time, in any court of competent jurisdiction), any disputes arising with respect to this Agreement shall be settled by arbitration in accordance with the rules and procedures of the Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Service, Inc. ("JAMS"). The arbitrator shall be selected by joint agreement of the parties. In the event the parties cannot agree on an arbitrator within thirty (30) days of the initiating party providing the other party with written notice that it plans to seek arbitration, the parties shall each select an arbitrator affiliated with JAMS, which arbitrators shall jointly select a third such arbitrator to resolve the dispute. The written decision of the arbitrator shall be final and binding on the parties and enforceable in any court. The arbitration proceeding shall take place in San Francisco, California, using the English language.

References