Please note that all submissions to the site are subject to the wiki's licence, CC 4.0 BY-SA, as found here
Discord: Difference between revisions
From Consumer Action Taskforce
Jump to navigationJump to search
m merge category for companies |
m Improved readability with formatting, more consistent punctuation and grammar. |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
| Logo = Discord.svg|thumb|The logo for Discord | | Logo = Discord.svg|thumb|The logo for Discord | ||
}} | }} | ||
Discord is a proprietary VoIP and instant messaging platform developed by Discord Inc. (formerly Hammer & Chisel). Launched in 2015, the service has grown to over 150 million monthly active users as of 2025. While primarily marketed toward gamers, Discord has expanded to serve various communities and use cases | Discord is a proprietary VoIP and instant messaging platform developed by Discord Inc. (formerly Hammer & Chisel). Launched in 2015, the service has grown to over 150 million monthly active users as of 2025. While primarily marketed toward gamers, Discord has expanded to serve various communities and use cases<ref name="about-company">[https://discord.com/company/ "About Discord | Our Mission and Values"]. April 15, 2024. ''Discord''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref>. | ||
== Consumer Protection Profile == | == Consumer Protection Profile == | ||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
* Server ban appeals process lacks transparency<ref name="community-guidelines"/> | * Server ban appeals process lacks transparency<ref name="community-guidelines"/> | ||
* Limited disclosure of recommendation algorithm factors<ref name="privacy-policy"/> | * Limited disclosure of recommendation algorithm factors<ref name="privacy-policy"/> | ||
* Vague about specific data retention | * Vague about specific data retention time frames<ref name="privacy-policy"/> | ||
* No clear disclosure of how content is used for platform improvement<ref name="privacy-policy"/> | * No clear disclosure of how content is used for platform improvement<ref name="privacy-policy"/> | ||
==== Freedom ==== | ==== Freedom ==== | ||
'''Status:''' Significant Concerns | '''Status:''' Significant Concerns | ||
* Mandatory binding arbitration with class action waiver for U.S. users<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | * Mandatory binding arbitration with class action waiver for U.S. users<ref name="terms-of-service"/> (Users could opt out until May 15, 2024 via email<ref name="terms-of-service" />) | ||
* Users must accept broad terms of service that allow unilateral changes<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | * Users must accept broad terms of service that allow unilateral changes<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | ||
* Can terminate accounts without prior notice at Discord's discretion<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | * Can terminate accounts without prior notice at Discord's discretion<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | ||
| Line 42: | Line 42: | ||
* Content may be retained by Discord even after deletion<ref name="privacy-policy"/> | * Content may be retained by Discord even after deletion<ref name="privacy-policy"/> | ||
* Server owners have limited recourse if their servers are banned<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | * Server owners have limited recourse if their servers are banned<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | ||
* Forced to use Discord's payment processing for all monetary transactions<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | * Forced to use Discord's payment processing for all monetary transactions<ref name="terms-of-service"/> | ||
== Forced Arbitration == | |||
[[File:Discord Terms Of Service update notice.png|thumb]] | |||
Forced arbitration was added to discord's Terms of Service on April 15, 2024<ref name="terms-of-service" />. This was notified to users via an email sent on March 30, 2024. Users could opt out of this by sending an email to opt-out notice to [email protected] until May 15, 2024. There is no longer a way to opt out of this as of January 16, 2025. | |||
== Consumer Protection Incidents == | == Consumer Protection Incidents == | ||
==== FTC Data Collection Investigation (Sep. 2024) ==== | ==== FTC Data Collection Investigation (Sep. 2024) ==== | ||
In September 2024, the [[Federal Trade Commission]] released a comprehensive report examining Discord's data collection practices as part of a broader investigation into social media platforms | In September 2024, the [[Federal Trade Commission]] released a comprehensive report examining Discord's data collection practices as part of a broader investigation into social media platforms<ref>[https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/Social-Media-6b-Report-9-11-2024.pdf "A Look Behind the Screens: Examining the Data Practices of Social Media and Video Streaming Services"]. September 2024. ''Federal Trade Commission''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref>. | ||
The investigation revealed Discord collects extensive user data, including: | '''The investigation revealed Discord collects extensive user data, including:''' | ||
* Message content and metadata | * Message content and metadata | ||
* Voice chat participation | * Voice chat participation | ||
| Line 55: | Line 59: | ||
* Device and location information | * Device and location information | ||
Particular concern was raised about: | '''Particular concern was raised about:''' | ||
* Collection of data from users under 13 | * Collection of data from users under 13 | ||
* Handling of minor user information | * Handling of minor user information | ||
* Inadequate age verification systems | * Inadequate age verification systems | ||
The FTC identified multiple areas where Discord's practices put users at risk: | '''The FTC identified multiple areas where Discord's practices put users at risk:''' | ||
* Identity theft exposure | * Identity theft exposure | ||
* Potential stalking risks | * Potential stalking risks | ||
| Line 66: | Line 70: | ||
* Mental health and emotional impact | * Mental health and emotional impact | ||
The FTC concluded that Discord's data practices created unacceptable risks for users, particularly minors, and called for significant reforms to the platform's privacy protection measures | The FTC concluded that Discord's data practices created unacceptable risks for users, particularly minors, and called for significant reforms to the platform's privacy protection measures<ref>Tolentino, Daysia (September 19, 2024). [https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/social-media-companies-engaged-vast-surveillance-ftc-finds-calling-sta-rcna171814 "Social media companies engaged in 'vast surveillance,' FTC finds, calling status quo 'unacceptable'"]. ''NBC News''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref>. | ||
==== Child Safety Concerns (Jun. 2023) ==== | ==== Child Safety Concerns (Jun. 2023) ==== | ||
| Line 73: | Line 77: | ||
35 separate cases were identified where adults were criminally charged with "kidnapping, grooming, or sexual assault" involving contacts initiated through Discord. Additionally, 165 criminal prosecutions involving the sharing of child sexual exploitation material on the platform were documented. | 35 separate cases were identified where adults were criminally charged with "kidnapping, grooming, or sexual assault" involving contacts initiated through Discord. Additionally, 165 criminal prosecutions involving the sharing of child sexual exploitation material on the platform were documented. | ||
Discord stated they had increased safety measures, including: | '''Discord stated they had increased safety measures, including:''' | ||
* Enhanced age verification systems | * Enhanced age verification systems | ||
* Improved automated detection tools | * Improved automated detection tools | ||
* Increased moderation staff | * Increased moderation staff | ||
Despite these measures, investigations showed continuing vulnerabilities in Discord's youth protection systems | Despite these measures, investigations showed continuing vulnerabilities in Discord's youth protection systems<ref>Winston, Ali (March 15, 2024). [https://web.archive.org/web/20250101094320/https://www.wired.com/story/764-com-child-predator-network/ "There Are Dark Corners of the Internet. Then There's 764"]. ''WIRED''. Archived from the original on January 1, 2025. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref>. | ||
==== Fined for GDPR Violations (Nov. 2022) ==== | ==== Fined for GDPR Violations (Nov. 2022) ==== | ||
In November 2022, France's privacy regulator [[CNIL]] imposed an €800,000 fine on Discord for multiple GDPR violations<ref>Brunoli, Joseph (November 18, 2022). [https://www.techzine.eu/news/privacy-compliance/94722/france-fines-discord-e800000-for-privacy-infractions/ "France fines Discord €800,000 for privacy infractions"]. ''Techzine Europe''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref> that demonstrated systematic privacy protection failures: | In November 2022, France's privacy regulator [[CNIL]] imposed an €800,000 fine on Discord for multiple GDPR violations<ref>Brunoli, Joseph (November 18, 2022). [https://www.techzine.eu/news/privacy-compliance/94722/france-fines-discord-e800000-for-privacy-infractions/ "France fines Discord €800,000 for privacy infractions"]. ''Techzine Europe''. Retrieved January 16, 2025.</ref> that demonstrated systematic privacy protection failures: | ||
* Background Process Violation: The application continued running in the background after users attempted to close it, collecting data without user awareness or consent | * '''Background Process Violation:''' The application continued running in the background after users attempted to close it, collecting data without user awareness or consent. | ||
* Voice Chat Privacy Issue: The platform failed to properly disconnect users from voice chats after session termination, potentially exposing private communications | * '''Voice Chat Privacy Issue:''' The platform failed to properly disconnect users from voice chats after session termination, potentially exposing private communications. | ||
* Security Standards Violation: Discord allowed users to create passwords with as few as six characters, falling below accepted security standards for protecting user accounts | * '''Security Standards Violation:''' Discord allowed users to create passwords with as few as six characters, falling below accepted security standards for protecting user accounts. | ||
* Data Protection Failures: The investigation revealed broader systematic failures in Discord's approach to user privacy protection and data handling | * '''Data Protection Failures:''' The investigation revealed broader systematic failures in Discord's approach to user privacy protection and data handling. | ||
== References == | == References == | ||
Latest revision as of 05:53, 17 January 2025
Discord
| Basic Information | |
|---|---|
| Release Year | 2015 |
| Product Type | Messaging/VoIP Platform |
| In Production | Yes |
| Official Website | https://discord.com |
Discord is a proprietary VoIP and instant messaging platform developed by Discord Inc. (formerly Hammer & Chisel). Launched in 2015, the service has grown to over 150 million monthly active users as of 2025. While primarily marketed toward gamers, Discord has expanded to serve various communities and use cases[1].
Consumer Protection Profile[edit | edit source]
Privacy[edit | edit source]
Status: Significant Concerns
- Collects extensive user data including messages, voice communications, and server participation[2]
- Retains personal information until deemed "no longer needed" with unclear retention periods[2]
- Processes user content for safety features and platform improvement[2]
- Shares data with related companies, vendors, and third-party service providers[2]
- Uses behavioral tracking across platform features for personalization[2]
- Maintains logs of IP addresses and device information[2]
- May store deleted messages for undefined periods[2]
- Claims broad rights to user-generated content through terms of service[3]
Transparency[edit | edit source]
Status: Moderate Concerns
- Privacy policy written in relatively clear language compared to industry standards[2]
- Provides clear community guidelines with defined enforcement procedures[4]
- Limited transparency regarding content moderation decisions[4]
- Unclear processes for handling law enforcement requests[2]
- Server ban appeals process lacks transparency[4]
- Limited disclosure of recommendation algorithm factors[2]
- Vague about specific data retention time frames[2]
- No clear disclosure of how content is used for platform improvement[2]
Freedom[edit | edit source]
Status: Significant Concerns
- Mandatory binding arbitration with class action waiver for U.S. users[3] (Users could opt out until May 15, 2024 via email[3])
- Users must accept broad terms of service that allow unilateral changes[3]
- Can terminate accounts without prior notice at Discord's discretion[3]
- Users grant perpetual, transferable license to their content[3]
- No option to opt-out of core data collection while using the service[2]
- Content may be retained by Discord even after deletion[2]
- Server owners have limited recourse if their servers are banned[3]
- Forced to use Discord's payment processing for all monetary transactions[3]
Forced Arbitration[edit | edit source]
Forced arbitration was added to discord's Terms of Service on April 15, 2024[3]. This was notified to users via an email sent on March 30, 2024. Users could opt out of this by sending an email to opt-out notice to [email protected] until May 15, 2024. There is no longer a way to opt out of this as of January 16, 2025.
Consumer Protection Incidents[edit | edit source]
FTC Data Collection Investigation (Sep. 2024)[edit | edit source]
In September 2024, the Federal Trade Commission released a comprehensive report examining Discord's data collection practices as part of a broader investigation into social media platforms[5].
The investigation revealed Discord collects extensive user data, including:
- Message content and metadata
- Voice chat participation
- Server membership and activity
- Device and location information
Particular concern was raised about:
- Collection of data from users under 13
- Handling of minor user information
- Inadequate age verification systems
The FTC identified multiple areas where Discord's practices put users at risk:
- Identity theft exposure
- Potential stalking risks
- Discrimination concerns
- Mental health and emotional impact
The FTC concluded that Discord's data practices created unacceptable risks for users, particularly minors, and called for significant reforms to the platform's privacy protection measures[6].
Child Safety Concerns (Jun. 2023)[edit | edit source]
An NBC News investigation in June 2023[7] uncovered widespread child safety issues on Discord, revealing systematic problems with the platform's user protection measures.
35 separate cases were identified where adults were criminally charged with "kidnapping, grooming, or sexual assault" involving contacts initiated through Discord. Additionally, 165 criminal prosecutions involving the sharing of child sexual exploitation material on the platform were documented.
Discord stated they had increased safety measures, including:
- Enhanced age verification systems
- Improved automated detection tools
- Increased moderation staff
Despite these measures, investigations showed continuing vulnerabilities in Discord's youth protection systems[8].
Fined for GDPR Violations (Nov. 2022)[edit | edit source]
In November 2022, France's privacy regulator CNIL imposed an €800,000 fine on Discord for multiple GDPR violations[9] that demonstrated systematic privacy protection failures:
- Background Process Violation: The application continued running in the background after users attempted to close it, collecting data without user awareness or consent.
- Voice Chat Privacy Issue: The platform failed to properly disconnect users from voice chats after session termination, potentially exposing private communications.
- Security Standards Violation: Discord allowed users to create passwords with as few as six characters, falling below accepted security standards for protecting user accounts.
- Data Protection Failures: The investigation revealed broader systematic failures in Discord's approach to user privacy protection and data handling.
References[edit | edit source]
- ↑ "About Discord | Our Mission and Values". April 15, 2024. Discord. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 "Discord Privacy Policy". April 15, 2024. Discord. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 "Discord's Terms of Service". April 15, 2024. Discord. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 "Discord Community Guidelines". April 15, 2024. Discord. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ "A Look Behind the Screens: Examining the Data Practices of Social Media and Video Streaming Services". September 2024. Federal Trade Commission. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ Tolentino, Daysia (September 19, 2024). "Social media companies engaged in 'vast surveillance,' FTC finds, calling status quo 'unacceptable'". NBC News. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ Goggin, Ben (June 21, 2023). "Child predators are using Discord, a popular app among teens, for sextortion and abductions". NBC News. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ Winston, Ali (March 15, 2024). "There Are Dark Corners of the Internet. Then There's 764". WIRED. Archived from the original on January 1, 2025. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
- ↑ Brunoli, Joseph (November 18, 2022). "France fines Discord €800,000 for privacy infractions". Techzine Europe. Retrieved January 16, 2025.
